Due diligence is the work that you do to check the facts of a deal before you invest. At the seed stage and at Series A, there is little data. Thus, the work is different from due diligence on a mature company.
This checklist puts the questions in order. Start with the questions that can stop the deal. Do the slow work only when the deal passes the fast checks.
1. Fast checks: can this deal return the fund?
Before you check the details, estimate the best possible outcome. If the company succeeds, how large can it become? Can your stake at the exit return a large part of the fund?
If the answer is no, stop. A small best case is a common reason to say no, and it is the fastest reason to find.
Also check that the deal fits your fund: the stage, the sector, the geography and the check size. A deal outside your strategy needs a clear reason from the partner who brings it.
2. The founders
Find what each founder did before this company. Look for work that shows the skill this company needs most. A technical product needs a founder who can build it. A sales-led company needs a founder who can sell.
Speak to people who worked with the founders. Ask the references what the founder did when a plan failed. Also find references that the founders did not give you.
Check how the founders split the equity and the roles. Check that each founder works full time on the company. Unclear roles cause problems later.
3. The market
Identify the customer who pays and the problem that the product solves for that customer. Make an estimate of the market from the number of possible customers and the price that each customer can pay. Do not use only a large market figure from a report.
Ask why this company can grow now. A change in technology, regulation or customer behaviour is a good reason. "The market is large" is not a reason.
Make a list of the competitors, including the old way to solve the problem. Customers often keep the old way because it is familiar.
4. The product and the traction
Use the product yourself, if you can. Speak to some customers. Ask each customer what they did before the product, and what they would do if the product stopped.
Check the data that the company gives you. Compare the numbers in the deck with the numbers in the bank statements, the billing system and the analytics tool. Small differences are normal. Large differences need an explanation.
At the seed stage, look at how fast the company learns. Compare the plan from some months ago with the result.
5. Legal and financial checks
Get the cap table and compare it with the legal documents. Check all convertible notes and SAFEs, because they change your ownership at conversion.
Make sure that the company owns its intellectual property. Each founder and each contractor who wrote code must assign the rights to the company.
Check that the company is correctly incorporated and that it has no open legal disputes. Ask a lawyer to do this part.
6. Write the decision
Write a short investment memo. Record the main reasons for the decision and the main risks. Also record what must be true for the investment to succeed.
Do this for each "no" as well as each "yes". Some years later, you can compare your reasons with the real outcomes. This is the only way to learn which checks help your fund.
Free template: Investment memo template