At the earliest stage, a company often has no revenue and an early product. Thus, investors judge the founders more than the company.
Judgment about people is easy to bias. A confident speaker or a familiar background can have too much effect. A written method makes the judgment more consistent.
Look at what the founder did, not what the founder says
Past work is the best evidence. Find things that the founder built, sold or led. Find what happened to them.
Look for evidence of speed. How long did the founder take to make the first version of the product? How long did they take to get the first customer?
Look for evidence of learning. Ask the founder about a plan that failed. A good answer tells what they learned and what they changed.
Match the founder to the company
Different companies need different skills. A deep technology company needs a founder who can solve the technical problem. A consumer company needs a founder who understands the customer and distribution.
Ask: why is this founder the right person for this specific problem? Specific knowledge of the market or the technology is a strong answer.
Check the founding team
Find how long the founders have known each other and if they worked together before. Ask each founder alone how they make decisions together.
Check that the skills of the team cover the most important work. Check that one person clearly owns each important area.
Use a scorecard
Write a short scorecard before you meet the founder. Use the same criteria for each founder. Score each criterion soon after the meeting, before a discussion with your partners.
Record the scores, and compare them with the outcomes some years later. This shows which criteria predict success for your fund.
IdeaPulley scores founders from their history and compares each score with a base rate for similar companies. Use a score like this as a second opinion, not as the decision.
Free template: Deal screening rubric template